The flat (identical in all three cases)
- Rent collected in the year, €12,000 (about 24 weeks of high-season letting)
- Documented expenses, €3,000 (community €1,100, IBI €450, cleaning €800, platform commissions €450, insurance €200)
- Cadastral value €120,000; days not rented 215
- All lets are 30 nights or fewer, so from 1 December 2026 the VAT question lands on all three identically (10 % on December stays)
The three bills (income tax, Form 210)
| Owner | Rule that applies | Rental tax | Empty-days tax (215 days) | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kowalski · tax resident in Poland (EU) | 19 % on net (rent €12,000 − €3,000 expenses) | €1,710 | €268.60 | €1,978.60 |
| Smith · tax resident in the UK | 24 % on gross, no deductions (pending appeal) | €2,880 | €339.29 | €3,219.29 |
| Müller · tax resident in Germany (EU) | 19 % on net | €1,710 | €268.60 | €1,978.60 |
Exact empty-day maths. €120,000 × 2 % = €2,400/year; × 215/365 empty days = €1,413.70; × 19 % = €268.60 (EU/EEA) or × 24 % = €339.29 (UK). Example only; a cadastral revision year gives 1.1 % instead of 2 %.
Sources arts. 24.1, 24.6 and 85 TRLIRNR; EU/EEA list per AEAT.Three lessons owners take from this table
- Passport irrelevant, pillow address decisive. What matters is where the owner is tax resident. Dual-residence edge cases are exactly what the tax-residency analysis is for.
- Invoices are worth €1,200/year to Mr Smith too. If the non-EU deductions ruling settles his way, his back years become refundable. Keep them.
- Nobody escapes the empty weeks. All three pay deemed income for the 215 days the flat sat closed; that part surprises everyone.

